Verzuz has become a highly anticipated event during the year for music fans for its celebration of artists. The list of stars who have appeared on the platform include the best pioneers of urban music such as Patti Labelle and Gladys Knight to rap stars like the late great DMX and R&B legends such as Brandy and Monica.

Apparently, L.A. Reid is also a fan of Swizz Beatz and Timbaland‘s ongoing battle series, too, and during an interview on The Real, he revealed what two artists would make for his “ideal” Verzuz.

“It’s Mariah Carey versus Beyoncé! Bring that on,” the legendary record executive said confidently. “The hits they have, the legacies they have. Bey is the queen, right? Sometimes Mariah might be slightly underrated for how long her career has lasted, how many hits she has, and she practically owns Christmas.”

Of course when fans of both iconic singers heard what L.A. Reid had to say, they jumped on social media to ponder what it would be like to see these two legendary women on a Verzuz. So many different talking points were made for both artists to take the W in a Verzuz. While many fans have been debating who would win in the hypothetical Verzuz battle, others feel like they wouldn’t be a good match-up since they are from two completely different generations. Also, some fans have joked that neither one of the artists would ever even agree to do a Verzuz, ultimately making this whole debate pointless.

Check out some of the Twitter reactions below, and let us know in the comments if you would be interested in seeing a Verzuz battle between Beyoncé and Mariah Carey.